Olivier Lewis
  • Home
  • Work
    • Work
    • Internships
    • Scuba Diving
    • News Articles
  • Study
    • Degrees
    • Current Research
    • Visiting Fellowships
    • Tutoring
    • Publications
    • Conferences
    • Invited Talks
  • Sport
    • Amateur
    • Professional
    • Fundraising
  • Music
  • Blog
  • Contact

sapere aude

terrorism studies & methodological rigor: The need for a Research Program?

8/27/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
Since the the CSTPV at St Andrews is organizing a symposium on "Terrorism Research: Past, Present and Future’", I thought I would make public my views on the topic. My main argument is not that provocative: throughout terrorism studies, the theories, models, concepts, and data used should be improved. My second argument, however, is that the best way to accomplish this might be through a research program -- a topic I will develop in a subsequent post.

Instead of binary thinking (rich/poor, religious/ideological, etc.), there should be more interest in variation within a concept and comparison between similar concepts. In other words, concepts such as religion, ideology, poverty, violence, etc., should be used in a more refined and precise manner and placed within a larger classification or typology. Similarly, any modeling of causation needs to include actors such as competing terrorist organizations, insurgent groups, criminal organizations, but also international organizations, states and their various agencies, civil society (NGOs, religious institutions, the private sector, the media, arts and entertainment), tribes, and especially the family and friendships.

These models could then be improved with several levels of analysis (international, regional, state, metropolitan, organizational, group, psychological, neurological) and the related emergent properties and theories thereof. For example, think of the effects on terrorism of factors such as armed conflict or peace; climate; education, health and income; constitutional and criminal law and regime type; social norms and values; collective memory and family history; personal religious and political beliefs, all of which vary across time and space.

Once all of these concepts and models are clearly established, it would be useful to seek to understand what types of social relationships and behaviors are stable and reoccurring and which are changing (either deliberately or not). This would require focusing on specific regions of the world, specific historical periods or specific types of terrorism before combining this knowledge at a higher geographical or conceptual level or in a larger historical period and theorizing interaction effects and path-dependency. For example, once all of this is done, research could try to model the spread of global trends and fashions in terrorism tactics (highjacking, suicide bombing, kidnapping, beheading, etc.) across space and time.

One way of organizing such progress would be through a research program, possibly based on scientific/critical realism and complexity theory, but I think that would not be very popular, for a number of reasons. Without such a program, however, the progress in terrorism studies is likely to remain piecemeal.

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Olivier Lewis

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    June 2018
    July 2017
    November 2016
    April 2016
    November 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Central Asia
    Central Europe
    Concepts
    Counterinsurgency
    Counterterrorism
    Covert Action
    Data Mining
    Frankfurt School
    Freedom Fighter
    Human Trafficking
    Insurgency
    Irregular Warfare
    NATO
    Order Theory
    Policy Transfers
    Political Violence
    Rendition
    Social Network Analysis
    South Eastern Europe
    Trump
    Truth
    Ukraine

    RSS Feed

    View my profile on LinkedIn
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photos used under Creative Commons from Rod Waddington, Răzvan Băltărețu, Bogdan Migulski, theglobalpanorama, wuestenigel, JMcCannSW162, quinet, workshoppe, Samuel Mann, rainerstropek@yahoo.com, peretzp, Capt' Gorgeous
  • Home
  • Work
    • Work
    • Internships
    • Scuba Diving
    • News Articles
  • Study
    • Degrees
    • Current Research
    • Visiting Fellowships
    • Tutoring
    • Publications
    • Conferences
    • Invited Talks
  • Sport
    • Amateur
    • Professional
    • Fundraising
  • Music
  • Blog
  • Contact