Olivier Lewis
  • Home
  • Academics
    • Degrees
    • Current Research
    • Visiting Fellowships
    • Tutoring
    • Publications
    • Conferences
    • Invited Talks
    • Blog
  • Work
    • Internships
    • News Articles
  • Sports
    • Amateur
    • Professional
    • Fundraising
  • Music
  • Contact

sapere aude

Military Cooperation vs. Covert Action Cooperation

4/17/2016

0 Comments

 


The United States government plans to increase military actions in Iraq and Syria, mostly through special and covert forces. But it is well known that such actions are not being conducted unilaterally.

Often times, transatlantic states will openly cooperate in military operations, but when such cooperation appears to go against laws, customs, or political and strategic interests, these states either stop cooperating or decide to cooperate covertly via their external intelligence agencies.

Consequently, the determination of whether a specific covert action is related to espionage or warfare has important legal, moral and policy consequences, e.g. concerning assignations and extrajudicial killings.

In the United States, as long as the national intelligence budget was totally classified, the Department of Defense ran many small special operations through the CIA, hiding the costs in the more opaque budget. Now, that both national and defense intelligence budgets are more transparent, there are calls to have small paramilitary operations be fully run by the Dept. of Defense. The problem is that the Dept. of Defense is a larger and thus slower organization.

It seems that the covert operation/overt military operations nexus has not been fully explored by social scientists. The literature seems to have a gap when it comes to explaining transitions from overt to covert military operations, and vice versa. This seems especially true concerning non-anglophone states. If you know studies of this type, please contact me or post them in the comments section.

Picture
0 Comments

conceptualizing counterinsurgency 

3/22/2014

0 Comments

 
Picture
As I am currently conducting an internship at the US Mission to NATO, I have not had much time to dedicate to my research. But I have managed to go to NATO's library during my lunch breaks. NATO's library holds a great number of books on insurgency and counterinsurgency. Moreover, these books are often grouped into a series of thematic bibliographies. One of my favorites is the one on irregular warfare. The library also develops a series of online guides, on subjects such as counterinsurgency in Afghanistan.

Looking through the thematic bibliography on counterinsurgency forces one to conclude that the study of irregular warfare is quite affected by terminological trends and fads. Year by year, the books often respond to the latest foreign policy debate. Being policy relevant is a laudable endeavor, but this should not come at the expense of analytical rigor. Rather than these two interests having to be balanced, I believe the former should be based on the latter -- policy guidance that is not based on analytical rigor could even be considered unethical.

The first step towards analytical rigor is conceptual clarity, and I ( and others) believe this is currently lacking in counterinsurgency studies and irregular warfare studies writ large. I would argue that those who seek to study current events should always critically examine the concepts they employ, especially when these concepts are borrowed from governments and the press. When scholars do not have the benefit of hindsight, they should always ask whether other concepts (terms and definitions) could better describe and differentiate their objects of study. We could start, for example, by asking: what is counterinsurgency? And then move on to asking: what is the opposite of counterinsurgency? With these answers in hand, we could then develop a universal conceptualization of counterinsurgency ready to be made operational in the study of any historical period, even the current one.


0 Comments

    Author

    Olivier Lewis

    View my profile on LinkedIn

    Archives

    July 2017
    November 2016
    April 2016
    November 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Central Asia
    Central Europe
    Concepts
    Counterinsurgency
    Counterterrorism
    Covert Action
    Data Mining
    Frankfurt School
    Freedom Fighter
    Human Trafficking
    Insurgency
    Irregular Warfare
    NATO
    Order Theory
    Policy Transfers
    Political Violence
    Rendition
    Social Network Analysis
    South Eastern Europe
    Trump
    Truth
    Ukraine

    RSS Feed

    View my profile on LinkedIn
Powered by
Photos used under Creative Commons from Rod Waddington, U.S. Embassy Tel Aviv, Bogdan Migulski, theglobalpanorama, wuestenigel, JMcCannSW162, workshoppe, Samuel Mann, rainerstropek@yahoo.com, peretzp, Capt' Gorgeous
  • Home
  • Academics
    • Degrees
    • Current Research
    • Visiting Fellowships
    • Tutoring
    • Publications
    • Conferences
    • Invited Talks
    • Blog
  • Work
    • Internships
    • News Articles
  • Sports
    • Amateur
    • Professional
    • Fundraising
  • Music
  • Contact
✕